New Soylent Screen Up!

[urbpan]

This time I complain about the endings to The Prestige! while admitting that I'd like Fight Club better if it was a TV show. If you would like to read the full thing go to BBT.


"Better than Swordfish."

Comments

[candent.livejournal.com]

IMO the basic problem with Fight Club is that it attempts to combine a subjective POV, an unreliable narrator describing a nonexistent character, and images that conform to the narrator's fantasy. Film makes images too physical and literal for that to work. Hitchcock complained that the book of "Psycho" cheated with sentences (not in Norman's voice) like "Mother did this," "Mother said that." FC is filled with similar outright cheats where the characters BOTH interact with either the physical world or third parties, and it has just as many loose ends, where you're left scratching your head, saying "that's odd." I have 10 or so key examples of this but I don't want to flood your post...

[urbpan.livejournal.com]

You explained what I hate about that movie much more eloquently than I've ever managed (and I try to, all the time).

Now do "Tank Girl."

Tank Girl

[candent.livejournal.com]

I enjoy dystopias but the movie takes itself too seriously to capture the outrageous fun of the comic (the violence and language is incredibly tepid), and tries to disguise directionless writing as camp. It's how "Mad Max" might have turned out had it been written by MTV VJs.

[dragonwrites.livejournal.com]

agreed. /the prestige/ was stupid and all the characters were petty jerks. heard the book was better; not compelled to check.

[(Anonymous)]

Fight Club has obviously been getting away with this shit to long. Let's go kick its ass! Everyone, get to your cars!

Don't laugh, Prestige, you're next!

--G

[http://users.livejournal.com/purplebunnie_/]

Well... I liked it, still. But I've come to not expect a whole lot from visual entertainment; I far prefer books.